Skip to content
  1. Home
  2. /
  3. Guides
  4. /
  5. Personal Injury

Contributory negligence in Maryland: what it means for your injury claim

In Maryland, being even slightly at fault can bar an injury claim. Here is how the rule works, the 2013 Coleman decision, and its exceptions.

Personal Injury · October 7, 2026 · 6 min read · Colbert Law Firm

Wooden gavel in front of two toy cars that have collided

Most states let an injured person recover something even if they were partly to blame, with the award reduced by their share of the fault. Maryland does not. Under contributory negligence, if you were even slightly at fault for your own injury, you can lose the right to recover anything from the person who was mostly to blame. It helps to know how it works before you talk to an adjuster.

What the rule says

Contributory negligence means the injured person did not take reasonable care for their own safety, and that carelessness helped cause the harm. In Maryland, that is a complete defense. It does not matter that the other side was more careless. If a jury finds you were negligent and your negligence contributed to the injury, the claim fails.

A fiscal note prepared for the General Assembly in 2026 says Maryland is one of only a few places that still follow the rule, along with three other states and the District of Columbia.

Coleman v. Soccer Association of Columbia (2013)

Maryland’s highest court, then called the Court of Appeals, looked at the rule again in Coleman v. Soccer Association of Columbia, decided July 9, 2013. James Coleman, a 20-year-old volunteer coach, was helping at a youth practice in Howard County. He jumped up and grabbed the crossbar of a soccer goal that was not anchored to the ground. The goal fell backward and the crossbar hit his face, causing fractures that needed surgery.

The jury found that the soccer association was negligent and that its negligence caused his injuries. It also found that Coleman was negligent and that his own negligence contributed. Because of that second finding, he recovered nothing.

Coleman asked the court to replace contributory negligence with comparative negligence. The court declined, as it had in 1983 in Harrison v. Montgomery County Board of Education. The majority said changing the rule was a policy decision for the General Assembly, which had repeatedly turned down bills to do it. Two judges dissented. The opinion is published on mdcourts.gov.

Is the legislature changing it?

Not yet. In 2026, House Bill 466 would have applied comparative negligence to motor vehicle cases involving a “vulnerable individual,” such as a pedestrian or cyclist. It was referred to interim study by the House Judiciary Committee on March 19, 2026, and did not pass. For now the rule applies the same way it did in Coleman.

Exceptions and limits

  • Last clear chance. If the injured person was negligent but the defendant then had a fresh opportunity to avoid the harm and failed to take it, the defendant can still be liable. The Coleman opinion describes this doctrine as a long-standing modification of the rule.
  • Young children. Coleman also notes that Maryland courts do not apply contributory negligence to a child under five.
  • Seat belts. Under Section 22-412.3 of the Transportation Article, not wearing a seat belt may not be treated as evidence of negligence or contributory negligence, and it may not reduce the damages you recover from a crash. Unless the case is about a faulty seat belt, nobody may bring it up at trial.
  • Both parts have to be shown. The question is whether you were careless and whether that carelessness helped cause the injury, which is what the jury was asked in Coleman. Being involved when something went wrong is not the same thing.

How insurers use it

Because one percent of fault can end a Maryland claim, adjusters look for anything that puts part of the blame on you. In a crash that might be a remark that you were glancing at your phone, running a little late or “didn’t see him until the last second.” After a fall in a store, it might be a question about whether you were watching where you walked.

That is why the other driver’s insurer often asks for a recorded statement early. You do not have to give one. Stick to facts with your own insurer, keep your photos and witness names, and do not guess about what caused the crash or fall. The steps in what to do after a car accident in Bowie and slip and fall in a store are written with this rule in mind.

Contributory negligence can also affect your own coverage. The Maryland Insurance Administration says uninsured motorist coverage applies only when the other driver is found 100 percent at fault. The uninsured driver guide explains more.

What about Washington, D.C.?

D.C. also follows contributory negligence in general, but a 2016 law (D.C. Code Section 50-2204.52) carved out pedestrians and “vulnerable users” such as people on bicycles, scooters, skateboards and motorcycles who are hit by a motor vehicle. For them, their own negligence bars recovery only if it was greater than the combined negligence of all the defendants. The same law keeps the last clear chance doctrine.

The personal injury page explains how the firm handles injury claims, and the car accident page covers crashes. Keep the Maryland statute of limitations in mind as well.

Common questions

Does contributory negligence in Maryland mean I get nothing if I was 1 percent at fault?

It can. If the jury finds you were negligent and that your negligence contributed to the injury, Maryland law bars recovery, unless an exception such as last clear chance applies.

Can the insurer blame me for not wearing a seat belt?

Not to defeat or reduce a Maryland car crash claim. State law says failing to wear a seat belt is not evidence of contributory negligence and does not reduce damages.

Who decides whether I was at fault?

The adjuster forms a view during the claim, but if the case goes to trial, the jury (or the judge, without a jury) decides based on the evidence, as the jury did in Coleman.

Should I admit fault at the scene to be polite?

No. Be courteous and stick to facts. An apology or a guess about the cause can be used against you later.

If you want to talk it through, request a consultation or call 301-576-6200.

This guide is general information about Maryland and D.C. law, not legal advice about your situation. For advice, talk to the firm.

Talk to a lawyer in Bowie this week.

Call, or send the form and the office replies the next business day.